Thrift stores are full of hidden treasures if you know where to look. From vintage clothes and rare vinyl to collectible toys and high-end handbags, expert thrifters have a knack for spotting valuable finds long before anyone else. Whether you’re a seasoned secondhand shopper or just starting out, knowing what the pros look for can turn a casual browse into a serious score. These 25 items are the first things thrift experts check for because they know what’s worth grabbing before it’s gone.
Collectible Toys
Secondhand stores often hide rare and collectible toys from various decades. Expert pickers often look for action figures, dolls, or vehicles from toy lines like Star Wars, Barbie, and Hot Wheels. Many toys from the ’80s and ’90s can be worth hundreds of dollars in mint condition or original packaging. Pickers search for toys that are either rare, discontinued, or part of limited edition runs. In some cases, toys with small manufacturing flaws or unique variations can actually increase in value. For example, certain Beanie Babies, action figures from well-known franchises, or even board games can yield impressive profits. Collectible toys have become a lucrative niche in the secondhand market for savvy pickers.
Designer Handbags
High-end designer handbags can be found in secondhand stores and are often one of the first items that expert pickers inspect. Brands like Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Prada, and Chanel are some of the most sought after. The materials, stitching, and overall condition of the bag are crucial for determining value. Vintage pieces or discontinued styles can often fetch higher prices due to their rarity. Expert pickers are skilled at spotting authentic designer items amidst counterfeits by checking for small details like hardware logos, interior stitching, and serial numbers. If you’re lucky enough to find one, it’s often a resale goldmine. The demand for designer handbags in both retail and resale markets ensures a strong return on investment.
Vintage Kitchenware
Vintage kitchen items like Pyrex bowls, Fire-King mugs, and old-school kitchen gadgets are popular with both collectors and home enthusiasts. These items are highly durable and often made from beautiful materials like glass, ceramic, and enamel. Expert pickers look for well-known brands or discontinued patterns, as they tend to be more valuable. Whether it’s a set of mid-century dinnerware or a retro toaster, there’s an increasing appreciation for vintage kitchen items, especially when they come in pristine condition. Some specific patterns and colors can become collector’s items, especially if they were produced in limited runs. Items that are complete or come with the original packaging can also command higher prices. Vintage kitchenware often has both functional and aesthetic appeal.
Vintage Clothing
Vintage clothing is one of the most sought-after categories in secondhand stores. Expert pickers love items from the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s, particularly pieces that are in excellent condition. These garments can feature unique fabrics, classic cuts, and even iconic designer labels that are hard to find today. Trends in fashion often recycle, so owning authentic vintage pieces can provide both a stylish and valuable wardrobe. Brands like Levi’s, Gucci, and Chanel are especially valuable in the resale market. Expert pickers will often look for pieces that are timeless and have the potential to be restored or repaired if needed. Clothing with unique features, like bold patterns or high-quality materials, is often a jackpot find.
Mid-Century Modern Furniture
Mid-century modern furniture is a favorite among collectors and designers, making it a prized find in secondhand stores. These pieces from the ’50s to ’70s often feature sleek lines, functional designs, and beautiful wood finishes. Expert pickers are quick to spot quality craftsmanship, such as solid wood construction and iconic brands like Herman Miller or Eames. Look for clean, minimalistic designs, sturdy legs, and items that still retain their original features. Whether it’s a coffee table, chair, or lamp, mid-century modern furniture can often be sold for a hefty profit or added to a home decor collection. A restored piece can easily fetch a high price at auctions or resale shops. For pickers, spotting a diamond in the rough is a thrilling experience.
Vintage Vinyl Records
For music enthusiasts, vintage vinyl records are always on the radar when browsing secondhand stores. Rare albums from artists like The Beatles, Pink Floyd, or David Bowie are highly coveted by collectors. The condition of the vinyl and the album cover plays a significant role in its value. Pickers often know that first pressings or limited editions are especially sought after. These records hold nostalgic value and often appreciate in price over time. A solid collection of old vinyl can be worth hundreds, if not thousands, depending on the rarity and condition. Expert pickers will often examine record bins for albums with desirable labels, pristine covers, or notable musicians.
Art Prints and Paintings
Art is a standout category for expert pickers, as it can be both an investment and a statement piece for any home. Collectible art prints, especially those by well-known artists, can carry significant value. Pickers focus on looking for signature pieces, limited edition prints, and works from emerging artists. Sometimes, older, unsigned pieces can still be worth a lot if they have a unique history or style. When browsing secondhand stores, a picker’s trained eye can spot valuable art, even if it’s not framed or is in poor condition. Restoring these pieces can significantly increase their value. Art found in secondhand stores often carries a sense of mystery and storytelling, adding to its charm.
Antique Jewelry
Antique jewelry can be a goldmine for expert pickers, especially when it comes to vintage pieces made of precious metals or featuring unique gemstones. Items like brooches, rings, necklaces, and watches are often sought after by collectors and resellers. Expert pickers will check the metals for authenticity (such as gold, silver, or platinum) and look for hallmarks or maker’s marks that indicate high-quality craftsmanship. Antique jewelry is often appreciated for its design, historical significance, and rarity. Even pieces that seem a little worn or outdated can be refurbished to hold modern appeal. Some expert pickers specialize in vintage and designer jewelry, identifying pieces with potential for restoration or re-sale. Certain pieces may even carry a fascinating backstory that adds to their charm and value.
Old Books and First Editions
Rare books, first editions, and antique volumes can fetch impressive prices in the secondhand market. Expert pickers often search for books that are in limited runs, especially those that are signed by the author or have historical significance. The condition of the book plays a critical role—collector’s items must be in excellent shape, free of tears or discoloration. First editions from famous authors like Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, or J.K. Rowling are especially valuable. Old books with intricate bindings, illustrations, or unique features can also appeal to collectors. Bookworms and bibliophiles appreciate these treasures for their historical value and connection to a time period or literary movement. Expert pickers know the importance of handling these items carefully to preserve their condition.
Vintage Cameras
Vintage cameras have experienced a resurgence in popularity, making them a desirable find for expert pickers. Old-school film cameras, especially from brands like Leica, Nikon, and Canon, often fetch a good price. Collectors appreciate the craftsmanship of these cameras, as well as the nostalgia they carry. Some cameras, particularly limited edition models or ones with unique features, can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Film photography is making a comeback, with enthusiasts preferring the authentic feel of manual cameras over digital. For pickers, spotting a rare camera in good working condition can lead to an exciting sale. Even if a camera is slightly damaged, it may still be valuable to the right buyer or for parts.
Vintage Typewriters
Typewriters from the mid-20th century are considered vintage treasures by both collectors and enthusiasts. Expert pickers seek out iconic brands like Underwood, Remington, and Royal. These machines are appreciated for their sturdy build, mechanical design, and aesthetic appeal. Many pickers search for working typewriters that are fully functional, but some will purchase non-working models if they are in pristine condition or have unique features. Typewriters were once indispensable for writers, journalists, and office workers, and they now evoke nostalgia for a simpler time. The trend for retro home decor has boosted the appeal of these machines. Restored or well-maintained typewriters often have strong resale value.
Antique Clocks
Old clocks, especially ones from the 18th and 19th centuries, are highly desirable for expert pickers. Whether it’s a grandfather clock, a mantle clock, or a pocket watch, these timepieces often have intricate craftsmanship and historical significance. Collectors appreciate the artistry of antique clocks, and they are often willing to pay top dollar for well-preserved items. Pickers look for unique designs, working condition, and established brands in the clock-making world. The materials used—such as brass, wood, and porcelain—are also key indicators of quality. Even clocks that are not in perfect working condition can be valuable, especially if they have collectible parts or could be easily restored. For some pickers, the thrill is in finding an heirloom-quality piece for a reasonable price.
Vintage Lighting Fixtures
Vintage lighting fixtures, including chandeliers, pendant lights, and sconces, are a common find that excites expert pickers. These items often boast distinctive designs from past decades and can provide a unique touch to any space. Whether it’s a mid-century modern fixture or an Art Deco chandelier, these items can be resold for impressive profits. Expert pickers know how to check the condition of the wiring and assess whether a light fixture needs any repairs or upgrades. Rare or designer fixtures, particularly from well-known lighting brands, are especially prized. The appeal of vintage lighting is often linked to both functionality and the ability to add character to a home. With restoration, these lights can shine bright once again.
Vintage Posters
Vintage posters, especially those from the mid-20th century, are valuable to both collectors and decorators. Movie posters, travel advertisements, and concert posters from iconic events or artists can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Pickers search for original prints, as these are generally much more valuable than reproductions. The condition of the poster is critical; any creases, tears, or fading can affect its value. A poster in mint condition, particularly a limited edition, can command top dollar. Pickers may also look for unusual or obscure posters that have cult followings or historical significance. These items can become focal points in interior design, as well as excellent investments.
Cast Iron Cookware
Cast iron skillets, Dutch ovens, and pans are always on an expert picker’s radar. Brands like Griswold and Wagner are particularly prized for their durability and craftsmanship. Even rusty or worn cast iron can be cleaned, re-seasoned, and brought back to life with a bit of elbow grease. Pickers look for smooth cooking surfaces, readable logos, and unique handle designs that can hint at the item’s age. Cast iron cookware not only holds value but is also incredibly functional for home chefs. These pieces can last for generations, making them a worthwhile investment. Their weight and solid construction are often good indicators of authenticity and quality.
Military Memorabilia
Items like medals, uniforms, insignias, and gear from past wars can be historically significant and highly collectible. Expert pickers look for authenticity—original patches, accurate dating, and proper materials like wool or canvas. WWII and Vietnam War memorabilia tend to be the most sought-after, especially items in good condition. Provenance or documentation can significantly increase the value of a military item. Pickers often research serial numbers, manufacturer stamps, and military unit associations. These artifacts tell stories from history and are often appreciated by museums, collectors, and veterans. Spotting a genuine piece can be like unearthing a piece of living history.
Retro Electronics
Old electronics like vintage radios, tube TVs, boomboxes, and early video game consoles are always in high demand. Brands like Sony, RCA, and Nintendo are popular with collectors and retro-tech fans. Working or restorable electronics can bring in top dollar, especially if they come with original packaging or manuals. Pickers test items (if possible) and check for missing parts or corrosion. Even non-functioning items can be valuable for parts or decorative purposes. Nostalgia plays a huge role in the popularity of retro electronics. For expert pickers, knowing which models are rare or in demand is key to making a smart purchase.
Board Games and Puzzles
Classic board games—especially those with original packaging and complete pieces—are another hidden gem in secondhand shops. Games like Monopoly (especially early editions), Risk, or obscure titles from the ’60s and ’70s can fetch high prices. Pickers often look for collector’s editions or discontinued games that are hard to find. Puzzle enthusiasts also prize vintage or artistically designed puzzles in good condition. The key is completeness—missing pieces can significantly reduce the value. Some board games gain cult followings, increasing demand over time. A sealed or barely used game can be a surprisingly valuable find.
Quilts and Handmade Textiles
Handmade quilts, especially those that are old, intricately designed, or regionally significant, can be quite valuable. Expert pickers assess the stitching, fabric, and patterns used to determine the quilt’s age and craftsmanship. Heirloom-quality quilts can sometimes fetch hundreds of dollars or more, depending on condition and uniqueness. Regional patterns or styles, like Amish or Appalachian quilts, are particularly desirable. Textiles that are clean, undamaged, and still vibrant in color are more valuable. These items also appeal to interior designers for their aesthetic appeal. For pickers, spotting a handmade treasure among a pile of linens is always a satisfying discovery.
Old Advertising Signs and Tins
Vintage advertising items, such as metal signs and branded tins, are highly collectible and frequently used in decor. Items with logos from Coca-Cola, Campbell’s, or old gas stations like Texaco are especially popular. Pickers look for original paint, minimal rust, and clear graphics, though some patina can add charm. These pieces tell a story about commerce and culture from past decades. Even small branded tins, like tobacco or coffee containers, can be worth collecting. The older and rarer the advertisement, the more valuable it typically becomes. Many of these items have crossover appeal between collectors and decorators alike.
Vintage Musical Instruments
Old guitars, violins, and brass instruments are regularly sought after by expert pickers. Well-known brands like Fender, Gibson, and Martin are particularly valuable, even in worn condition. Pickers look for signs of quality craftsmanship, such as solid wood construction and well-aged finishes. Instruments with serial numbers and original cases often bring higher prices. Some vintage instruments, especially rare models, have even appreciated more than stocks over time. Even obscure or regional brands can hold value with the right collector. The growing interest in analog music gear has only increased the demand for these classic instruments.
Vintage Luggage and Trunks
Old suitcases, steamer trunks, and travel bags from the early 20th century are both stylish and collectible. Brands like Samsonite, Louis Vuitton, or Hartmann are especially desirable. Expert pickers look for solid construction, original lining, and working hardware like clasps and locks. These pieces often find new life as decorative items or upcycled furniture. Trunks with travel stickers or personalized markings are considered even more special. A good-condition vintage luggage piece can command a premium in the resale market. For pickers, these items offer both function and flair.
Vintage Eyewear
Old-school glasses and sunglasses are stylish, collectible, and often quite valuable. Brands like Ray-Ban, Persol, or designer labels like Gucci and Dior are particularly sought after. Pickers look for high-quality frames made of metal, acetate, or horn, and especially love unique shapes like cat-eye or aviator styles. Even if the lenses are scratched, the frames alone can be worth a good deal to collectors or optical shops that specialize in retro fits. Vintage eyewear appeals to both fashion-forward buyers and costume designers. Some rare models can fetch hundreds of dollars depending on condition and rarity. A good eye for stylish frames can uncover hidden gold in a bin of accessories.
Vintage Barware and Cocktail Sets
Retro barware—from etched glasses to cocktail shakers and decanters—is hot in the resale and home decor market. Pickers look for complete sets, mid-century styles, or novelty items that add flair to a home bar. Brands like Culver, Libbey, and Georges Briard are well known for quality and design. Gold-rimmed glasses, ice buckets, and classic bar tools in original boxes are especially valuable. Expert pickers also pay attention to condition—chips, fading, or clouding can impact value. With the resurgence of vintage-style entertaining, these pieces have gained popularity. A stylish set of vintage barware can sell quickly to collectors or interior decorators.
Ceramic Figurines
Ceramic figurines are a popular collectible and often overlooked treasure in secondhand shops. Expert pickers seek out pieces from renowned makers like Royal Doulton, Hummel, Lladro, and Lefton. These figurines often depict animals, children, or elegant ladies in period dress and can range from highly realistic to whimsically stylized. The most valuable ones usually have a maker’s mark, mold number, or country of origin stamped or engraved on the base. Condition is critical—chipped or cracked figurines usually lose much of their value, though rare models may still be worth something. Limited editions or figurines tied to specific collections tend to be more sought-after. For pickers, spotting a dusty shelf full of old knick-knacks could mean discovering a miniature porcelain fortune.